Difference between revisions of "Nomic 2/Proposals/Beyond Hulk"
From RPG Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Created page with "== Proposal == 1) The Anger stat has no upper bound. 2) Whenever an Anger Check of difficulty N is required, and the player has an anger A, then the player rolls AdN. 3) If n...") |
(→Voting) |
||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
1) The Anger stat has no upper bound. | 1) The Anger stat has no upper bound. | ||
2) Whenever | 2) Whenever a Stat Check of difficulty N is required, and a player's Stat is a number X, then the player rolls XdN. | ||
3) If none of the dice come up 1, the | 3) If none of the dice come up 1, the Stat Check fails. | ||
4) Conversely if at least one dice comes up 1, the Stat Check succeeds. | |||
5) If X is non-positive, then the check fails automatically. | |||
''Don't make me any angrier. You would like me even less.'' | |||
== Proposed by == | == Proposed by == | ||
| Line 13: | Line 19: | ||
== Comments == | == Comments == | ||
When anger checks may be triggered and what is the effect of their failure of success is left for future rules to determine. | When anger checks may be triggered and what | ||
is the effect of their failure of success is left for future rules to determine. | |||
I'm guessing this is for a new rule. Sounds good to me. But a few thoughts: | |||
* It might be convenient to also note at the end that if at least one die comes up 1, the check succeeds (or that if it does not fail, it succeeds), since as it stands, the rule doesn't actually define anything other than failure. | |||
* Why not generalize parts 2 and 3 so they could be applied to any Stat? | |||
* You'll probably want to actually add a link to it from the Proposals page so people can find it. Also, don't forget the Flavour Text. | |||
--[[User:Jota|Jota]] 06:16, 12 February 2012 (PST) | |||
== Voting == | == Voting == | ||
* Jota: Aye | |||
* Olethros: Aye | |||
== Proposal Status == | == Proposal Status == | ||
Latest revision as of 14:13, 27 February 2012
Proposal
1) The Anger stat has no upper bound.
2) Whenever a Stat Check of difficulty N is required, and a player's Stat is a number X, then the player rolls XdN.
3) If none of the dice come up 1, the Stat Check fails.
4) Conversely if at least one dice comes up 1, the Stat Check succeeds.
5) If X is non-positive, then the check fails automatically.
Don't make me any angrier. You would like me even less.
Proposed by
--Olethros 02:09, 12 February 2012 (PST)
Comments
When anger checks may be triggered and what is the effect of their failure of success is left for future rules to determine.
I'm guessing this is for a new rule. Sounds good to me. But a few thoughts:
- It might be convenient to also note at the end that if at least one die comes up 1, the check succeeds (or that if it does not fail, it succeeds), since as it stands, the rule doesn't actually define anything other than failure.
- Why not generalize parts 2 and 3 so they could be applied to any Stat?
- You'll probably want to actually add a link to it from the Proposals page so people can find it. Also, don't forget the Flavour Text.
--Jota 06:16, 12 February 2012 (PST)
Voting
- Jota: Aye
- Olethros: Aye
